What are the Boundaries of Anti-semitism?-- Harold Zwier
This article, by AJDS Executive member Harold Zwier was published, in a very slightly modified form in the Australian Jewish News of 2 Feb 2012. The AJN version is attached below.
Recently The Age newspaper reported that the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ) had complained to the SBS ombudsman about a fictional drama, The Promise, shown on SBS late in 2011. The drama is set against the historical background of Palestine at the end of the British Mandate 1947/48 and Israel in 2005.
The main contention of the ECAJ is summed up in this quote from their complaint to SBS.
"The basic concept of The Promise, and the premises on which it rests, are ... not merely a gross misrepresentation of history, they also fall squarely within the ... Working Definition of Antisemitism."
The showing of The Promise pushed all the wrong buttons in the Jewish community. It is an unsentimental and unflattering portrait of Israel's creation. The portrayal of Jews is less sympathetic than those of the Arabs. The main Jewish family depicted in modern day Israel is wealthy. The historical narrative is biased towards the Arabs.
Update: SBS Ombudsman's ruling on "The Promise"
The SBS Ombudsman rejected the complaints made by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry and others against The Promise.
The text of the SBS response and the lack of satifaction it provides hard liners can be seen at Galusaustralis.
Forbidden discrimination, permitted discrimination-- Anat Saragusti
This article by Anat Saragusti, a guest of the 2008 Melbourne LimmudOz conference was not offered to readers of the English Haaretz.
It has been translated as a public service by Sol Salbe of the Middle East News Service of Melbourne, Australia. It has been made available with Sol's permission for those without Facebook Accounts.
Hebrew original: http://www.haaretz.co.il/opinions/1.1623616Opinions
Forbidden discrimination, permitted discrimination Anat Saragusti 23/01/12
